Tribes, empires and nation states
Borders
When dinosaurs roamed the earth, they did not pay attention to national borders, geopolitical boundaries, or what country they were in - in fact, countries as we know them didn't exist!
These are all human ideas, rooted in power (politics), money (economics), and social factors (including culture). More people have died for their
nation state than any other reason, with World War II reaching an estimated death toll of 75 million people. How does this happen?
Empires
Before independent nations, there were two major forms of societal organisation:
- tribes: smaller communities which self-organised at a local level
- empires: larger communities which invaded other parts of the world and declared them theirs
The modern Australian nation state was established as part of the British Empire, which at its peak encompassed about a quarter of the world's population at the end of the 19th century, across more than 33,700,000 km2!
Watch the next video for a quick overview of some empires and their territorial reach. As you watch, take note of how many empires were impacted on by the two World Wars.
Playing time: 10:18
Historical empires (5 coins)
- Create a list of five historical empires, and find the following facts for each empire:
- the total area of land they laid claim to at a particular point in time
- the total population under their rule at that point in time
- For each empire, calculate the following two values:
- the land laid claim to as a percentage of Earth's total land above water (roughly 500,000,000 km2)
- the population under their rule as a percentage of the earth's total population at that point in time (you can find the total human population by year here)
- Upload your list to the 'Historical empires submission'.
Tribes
Ever since the beginning of human history, people have tried to conquer one another's land, extending their sphere of control. The next video differentiates between a community, a movement, and a tribe.
Playing time: 7:38
Tribal definition (5 coins)
The video above argues that a tribe is defined by the existence of a common enemy. Answer the following questions in at least two sentences each, and post your answers on the 'Tribal definition forum':
- Do you agree that members of a tribe necessarily have a common enemy? Why or why not?
- Why else might a tribe form?
- Find another definition of tribe supports your ideas, or come up with a definition that's broader than the one in the video above.
From tribalism to the nation state
A nation state is a clearly bounded area of land ruled by its own government, inhabited by people who have a shared identity. The next video outlines the concept further:
Playing time: 8:51
Australian nation state (5 coins)
Consider the notion of the nation state as it applies to Australia, then answer the following questions on the 'Australian nation state forum', in at least
two sentences per question. You can post in response to someone else and comment on what they have said in your answer, or you can start a new thread.
- Which identity is more important to you: your national identity (i.e. 'Australian'), state identity (e.g. 'South Australian', 'Victorian' etc.), or ethnic identity?
- Are there cultural differences between the different states and territories in Australia?
- Does your regional identity differ depending on context?
Territorialism
Territory
Territorialism stems from the idea that people can own land, and that there are rights associated with land ownership. Land owned by a particular person or group is sometimes referred to as their 'territory'.
Territorialism can affect people at an individual level through their right to own a home, and at a national or international level when different cultural groups claim territorial independence and strive to establish their own nation states. For example, the Balkan states split from Russia, and more recently, South Sudan split from the Republic of the Sudan in 2011.
The legacy of empire
Because the nation state is such a complex idea, the notion of land ownership can vary around the world. In Zimbabwe, for instance, there has been a movement to challenge the right of foreigners to own land. This began in response to unequal land ownership created by the British Empire's former occupation of the area, under which it was called 'Rhodesia'
. Zimbabwe is just one of many modern nation states that continue to be affected by the legacy of empire.
The British Empire in particular created many difficult issues that remain unresolved to this day. Around 700 distinct language groups lived in Australia before the British Empire invaded Australia, beginning with the First Fleet in 1788
. Indigenous Australian populations still seek legal recognition for land that was taken from them.
The next video outlines the Mabo Case which introduced the legal concept of native title to Australia:
Playing time: 3:25
Native title (5 coins)
Native title cannot be granted over private property, so the courts still privilege private land ownership over native ownership. Is this fair? Post your thoughts on the 'Native title forum'. Feel free to respond to someone else's post or start a new thread. Be sure to give reasons for your view, and write at least three sentences.
War
The causes of war
We can start to understand how wars break out by drawing on the concepts of empire, land ownership, and the nation state. Wars occur for all sorts of reasons, but we can identify some common themes:
- Some wars involve a group of people fighting for independence from an empire, and the establishment of their own nation state. The American Revolutionary War (1775-1783), for example, saw the British colonies in America fight for independence against the empire.
- Civil wars are fought between different cultural or political groups within the same nation. Examples include t
he American Civil War (1861-1865), the Spanish Civil War (1936-1939), and various wars in the Middle East where different religious groups have fought to govern one another.
- World War I (1914-1918) and World War II (1939-1945) were especially complex, fought for a multitude of reasons. One central motivation was territory - either the effort to expand it by invading other countries, or to stop
this from happening.
The next video is made by an ex-soldier who reflects on his own experience and the nature of war.
Playing time: 8:06
Causes of war (5 coins)
- Select a war of your choice and research its causes, then answer the following questions in a total of at least six sentences:
- When and where did the conflict occur?
- Who were the major players and what were their motivations?
- What sequence of events lead to the conflict?
- Post your response on the 'Causes of war forum', along with a reference list.
International law
There are rules that specify how wars should be fought, and how people should be treated during a war. These rules are governed by international law, and people can be prosecuted for war crimes if they break them. This video provides a bit more information about international law:
Playing time: 4:43
ICC database (5 coins)
War criminals are sometimes prosecuted by the International Criminal Court in The Hague, Netherlands.
- Choose a case from the ICC website and find the following:
- The name of the accused
- A photograph of the accused
- A description of the charges
- The stage of proceedings (pre-trial, trial etc.)
- The outcome, if the trial has finished
- One other interesting fact about the case
- Create a page for that case on the 'ICC Wiki', including all the information above.
Peace
The United Nations
Several international unions formed after World War II, as nation states realised the importance of peace and unity moving forward. The United Nations was established at this time to prevent future wars. They are
non-interventionist, so they refrain from interfering with the affairs of nation states without sufficient justification. Because they strive to keep the peace, they attempt to resolve conflict using non-violent means such as diplomacy.
My Peace Prize (5 coins)
You can read a list of Nobel Peace Prize laureates here. If you could award a peace prize to anyone, who would it be and why? You're free to choose a public figure or someone you know personally. Post
your response in the 'My Peace Prize winner forum' to publically recognise your nominee.
Activities
Complete at least 25 coins' worth of activities below.
Terra nullius (5 coins)
When Captain Cook landed in Australia in 1770, he declared the land 'terra nullius,' which means 'nobody's land'. He then proceeded to claim Australia for the British Empire (as it was then). In actual fact, people had lived in Australia for at least 65,000 years. When the British arrived, there were over 750,000 indigenous people living in over 250 different language groups.
- Was Captain Cook's claim legitimate? Why or why not?
- How do you think legal ownership of land should be determined? Why?
Post your response on the 'Terra nullius forum'.
Tribes (10 coins)
Even in modern nation states, people identify with various 'tribes', or group identities. A sports team is a form of tribe, for example, defined by loyalty and the presence of a common enemy. Brand loyalty can also become a form of group affiliation
- some people like Apple iPhones, but others prefer Android devices. Consider the groups you belong to, and answer the following questions on the 'Tribes forum'. Write a total of at least five sentences:
- What groups do you belong to?
- How do you show that you belong to them?
- Could any of these groups be thought of as a tribe? Why or why not? Think about group loyalty, and the notion of a common enemy.
War machines (10 coins)
Military technology has evolved throughout human history.
- Choose a place and time with its own military tradition, at least 100 years in the past. Examples include World War I, ancient Greece, medieval England, and Japan during the Edo period.
- Choose an area of military technology that applies to your chosen historical moment. Examples include: guns, melee weapons, medicine, clothing, armour, surveillance, communications, armoured vehicles, missiles, the navy, the air force
.
- Produce an infographic, website or educational video about the development of your chosen area of military technology to the present day. You should also comment on where that technology might develop in future. You can read about how to make infographics, websites and videos here.
- Add your infographic, website or video to the main page of the 'War machines Wiki'. You can read about how to edit a Wiki here.
Mabo Case (15 coins)
War crime film review (15 coins)
Note that this activity may contain distressing material.
The Reader (2008) is a book subsequently made into a film about a young woman who is prosecuted for war crimes, having been a guard at a Nazi concentration camp during World War II. Take a look at the trailer below:
Playing time: 1:47
- Read and/or Watch The Reader (2008) and take notes on the justification Hanna Schmitz gives for her actions.
- Write a review of the film, considering the case for and against finding her guilty. Your review should be at least 300 words.
- Upload your review to the 'War crime film review submission'.
Conscription debate (15 coins)
'Conscription' refers to compulsory military service. Several nations have compulsory military conscription for nearly all young adults, including Israel and South Korea. In Australia, conscription was restricted to home service during
World War I, but conscripts were sent to New Guinea and the surrounding islands during World War II. Conscripts were also sent overseas during the Vietnam War (1955-1975).
- Like Australia, the US conscripted young men during the Vietnam War. Watch this video, where Rick Hazen shares his experiences as a draftee.
Note that the video may contain distressing material.
- After watching the video, write at least three sentences on the 'Conscription forum' explaining what you would do if you received a letter telling you to fight overseas or face two years' jail time. Feel free to start a new thread or
respond to someone else's post.
- Write a persuasive speech arguing for or against the following debate motion:
'Australia should have compulsory military service for young adults'.
You can post your speech as a new discussion on the 'Conscription forum', or you can write it in response to someone else's speech. For example, if someone else argues for the motion, you can respond to them with an argument against
it.
Imperial history (20 coins)
For this activity, you will create an educational video or podcast about a particular empire.
- Choose an empire that existed prior to World War I, aside from the British Empire.
- Research the empire and noting key facts, being careful not to get bogged down in too much detail. Be sure to note where you get your information from, so you can write a reference list later. Here are some key facts you might like to include:
- the name of the empire
- where and when it existed
- how it came into being
- its system of government
- its culture
- its military
- who it invaded
- life under the empire
- its fall (if appropriate)
- Write a script including an introduction and an overview of the history of the empire, including some or all of the facts above. Aim for at least 650 words, or about five minutes of speech.
- Record yourself reading the script in either audio or video format.
- Edit your recording into either a podcast episode or an educational YouTube video. If you are making a video, you might like to include pictures, video clips, text, and other visual media.
- Add a reference list to the end of your video or podcast episode, or in the upload description.
- Post your work on the 'Imperial history forum' for others to see.
National history (20 points)
- Select a country (other than Australia).
- Create a timeline of the area's history, from the earliest records to the establishment of the modern nation state that exists there at present. Include at least
six points on your timeline, along with at least one sentence of information for each one.
- Add an image to each point on your timeline.
- Add your timeline to the 'Nation state Wiki' alongside other countries.